What if you had to cast your ballot for either the white trollop or the black baby mama?

Well, if you did, you would obviously base your vote on Michelle’s original recipes verses Cindy’s plagiarized ones (cuz cooking is one of the main things women are good for besides opening their legs, popping out babies, and housework).

Or, you might consider their fashion know-how. But, how to weigh up Cindy’s Vogue pose in size zero jeans verses Michelle’s violet sheath dress? As Caren Bohan reports at Yahoo News, Cindy and Michelle are “both known for an elegant sense of style, lending glamour to their husbands’ campaigns.” Well, thank goodness for that. What is more important in a first lady than lending style and glamour to her supportive role as presidential arm candy?

For those of you who like a ‘traditional first lady,’ you may wish to cast your ballot for Cindy, a former rodeo queen and cheerleader who knows how to be properly submissive – or, as Bohan puts it “McCain’s deferential manner puts her in the company of more traditional first ladies such as Nancy Reagan and Laura Bush.” However, if you like good home-cooking alongside your deference, Cindy may not be your choice – at least not if what has been dubbed “Recipgate” is any indication of her cooking know-how. It seems Cindy’s “elegant and healthful offerings” were in fact lifted from the Food Network website. Oh well, should we expect a millionairress to get her nails dirty in the kitchen? Perhaps it should be enough that she is blonde haired and blue eyed (and did not ‘insult’ stay at home mothers as Hillary supposedly did some years ago with her infamous “I suppose I could have stayed home and baked cookies and had teas” comment*).

No, Cindy seems to know her place, at least if the Times Online has it right:

Cindy McCain, now 53, claims she has no interest in policy making – “I am not the legislator in this family. He is” – and that she intends to keep busy running her charities and her family’s company.

Ah, thank goodness. Wouldn’t want her pretty little head getting all muddled up in politics. However, you may want to take Cindy’s apparent heavy handedness with the makeup into account before you make your final decision. According to John, she “plaster(s) on the makeup like a trollop.” John also calls her a “cunt,” so, despite her rodeo queen cheerleading looks, she may not be the model first lady after all. (for more on John’s use of the c word, see Jill’s post at feministe “Yes we cunt”)

As for Michelle, well, if you are looking for more of an Eleanor Roosevelt of Rosalynn Carter style first lady, she might be your woman. However, if you like a woman who keeps her mouth shut, Michelle isn’t the lady for you. As the Times Online notes,

At the beginning of the campaign, Michelle Obama had confessed that her husband was a mere mortal with sloppy housekeeping habits who was “stinky and snorey” to cuddle with. Her frank, only half-joking criticism was emasculating, critics said, and she quickly gave up that line.

Friends have told her to tone down her remarks and play up her patriotism, but she has an angular style that is difficult to subdue.

Ugh, difficult to subdue? Doesn’t sound like she deserves to don the Nancy Reagan role.

In all seriousness, the reporting tactics cited above should cause a national gag reflex. How is it that “recipegate” can be news? Who gives a flying fig what recipes these women (or their partners) fancy? Does your lemon shortbread know-how translate into how soon you will bring the troops home? Do those size zero jeans signify your dedication to mitigating world hunger? The stereotypical sexism is abhorrent here, too. When do you ever hear about a candidate’s husband’s cooking acumen or fashion know-how? Bill was perhaps the first male partner to garner so much focus due to his former presidential status. Needless to say, he didn’t do a Vogue photo shoot or wax poetic about his love of baking down-home meals.

In the latest battle of what Maureen Dowd calls “the sulfurous national game of kill the witch,” it seems the media has definitely decided Michelle is the wicked witch and Cindy is, if not the princess, at least the good witch. In fact, the attacks against Michelle are coming so fast and furious that a new blog named Michelle Obama Watch dedicates itself to tracking the media onslaught against her. Unsurprisingly, no such blog is needed for Cindy as she is not only a POWP (person of white privilege), but she is also a ‘properly submissive’ wife (at least according to the media).

Michelle, on the other hand, has opinions and states them. She does not defer to her spouse or act as if he is master of the domain. She is intelligent, erudite, well-spoken, and confident. She is, in other words, human (rather than a mannequin sidekick ala Nancy or a smiling robot ala Laura). Yet, as Cara at the Curvature writes, “Any candidate’s wife who doesn’t stand a polite ten paces behind her husband and keep her mouth shut except to smile gets this sexist shit. When you add race into the mix, it all gets multiplied, and we’re watching it happen right now.” Yes, multiplied into what Angry Black Bitch dubs “Fox baby mama fucktuptitude.” It is apparently ok when Fox calls black women ‘baby mama,’ but the term whitey is somehow deeply offensive. (see Jill’s post at feministe for more on this racist double standard)

In fact, the negative stereotypes surrounding black women are so pervasive that Diary of an Anxious Black Woman suggests Michelle’s dreadful double sin (she is a woman and she is black!) could undermine Obama’s campaign:

Obviously, there seems to be a certain kind of cognitive dissonance that takes place in which black women, regardless of who we are, cannot be separated from the main stereotypes that abound about our bodies. That has been our “burden of representation.” Michelle Obama, an Ivy League graduate, professional lawyer, respectable wife and mother, and potential First Lady, is somehow reduced to the “baby mama”/”video ho” that is currently in heavy rotation and circulation. This image is so thoroughly ingrained in our culture as the antithesis of the “All-American Girl/Woman/Lady” that it really could undermine Obama’s chances at winning the presidency – yes, more undermining than any scary black man image that has been in circulation.

So, it doesn’t matter if Cindy cut and pasted her recipes from the Food Network, it doesn’t matter about her shady tax returns or her practice of stealing drugs from charity. It doesn’t matter she demeans herself by standing by a man who calls her a cunt. What matters is that Michelle has black skin. That, in and of itself, makes her suspect in our white supremacist society.

Moreover, it doesn’t matter what these women have or have not accomplished because in the eyes of the mainstream media, they are suspect merely because they are women. As the sexist onslaught against Hillary made patently clear, our society is far from post-feminist. If our society had taken on the equality messages of feminism, women would not be focused on as the cookie baking wives of candidates (as in Parents magazine’s presidential cookie bake off contests) nor as the witches who shouldn’t be running in the first place.

I still wish I could vote for Elizabeth Edwards, Cynthia McKinney, Maxine Waters, or Cindy Sheehan for president–and I don’t give a flying toss whether they can bake a crunchy oatmeal cookie. I would prefer, however, that they did not wear size zero jeans. (I have a preference that people who eat regularly run the country – food does the brain good — ok, so some brains need more than food to run, but all brains, even those of the very tiny reptilian variety (ala Bush) run better with food).

So, as you go about your daily business of deciding which politicians deserve your vote, I hope you will also make note of (and complain about) the sexist and racist worldview the mainstream media offers you, even if you do like cookie recipes.

The URI to TrackBack this entry is: http://professorwhatif.wordpress.com/2008/06/18/what-if-you-had-to-cast-your-ballot-for-either-the-white-trollop-or-the-black-baby-mama/trackback/

RSS feed for comments on this post.

15 CommentsLeave a comment

  1. The “trollop” is too stoic for my liking. Something about inheriting fortune that I really have a prejudice against. I wasn’t surprised about her stealing the recipes. With these misconceptions about urban Black women, I think it’s hard for many Americans to believe that she’s atypical of the conventional thinking (meaning ghetto) and acceptable to all of us. And a fist-pound? How do you make a spin story out of that. The “ghettoization” of Mrs. Obama is really disheartening. She’s from a working family that had its roots in inner city of Chicago and has proven herself very resilient.
    I agree with the part about Elizabeth Edwards. She’s very inspiring. I understand Cindy Sheehan’s plight and why she does what she does, but I’m not so sure about her.
    But I must say, I loves me a good baker!

  2. First off, I would never-ever-ever wish rape on a single individual but if I should ever do so, pal Clayton Williams would most certainly be the first on my list. I suppose a persons right to NOT BE RAPED has become as out of that persons hands as the weather…or so the young republican from the great state of texas has decided to publicly announce.
    Secondly, Im pretty sure good ol’ cindy the rodeo star will have my vote…hell her price winning peanut butter cookie recipe may just be able to sell enough to drag this country out the trillions of dollars of debt we’ve racked up in the last 8 years…and will undoubtedly continue to do so if her husband where to make his way to the oval office.
    Unopinionated and a 0-waist line…the perfection that is an ALL-AMERICAN GIRL!

  3. Thanks for your response, Minority Militant. See Cindy for Congress and maybe you will become a convert. I like her “let’s shut the war-machine down” stance. I like good bakers too, but don’t factor this in to who to vote for…

    And Jesse, never would of guessed such a soft-spot for Cindy from you. I think this bespeaks to a peanut butter addiction or a misplaced fondness for pink cowgirl boots. Either way, get yourself some help. Michelle is the winning ticket — and she makes a mean apple cobbler.

  4. I just added your link to my original post. What you wrote can only be described as TKO. Well said!!!!

  5. [...] What if you had to cast your ballot for either the white trollop or… This image is so thoroughly ingrained in our culture as the antithesis of the "All-American Girl/Woman/Lady" that it really could undermine… [...]

  6. [...] While many First Ladies have taken strong political stances and served in ways far beyond that of “hostess,” this “wifely support” concept of the First Lady’s role still reigns.  Much attention is paid to how she looks, dresses, acts, smiles, walks, etc, etc. Much criticism reigns down when she is seen as too strong, too political, too opinionated, too outspoken. Much better that she serve as presidential arm candy and meal planner! (For more in this vein, see my earlier post here.) [...]

  7. [...] is author of the blogs Professor, what if…? and Seduced by Twilight. She has written guest posts at blogs such as Womanist Musings, Girl with [...]

  8. “It is apparently ok when Fox calls black women ‘baby mama,’ but the term whitey is somehow deeply offensive.”

    Yeah, that is one that I’ve been trying to figure out for awhile, too…

  9. Hey. I was considering adding a link back to your site since both of our web sites are based
    mostly around the same subject. Would you prefer I link to you using
    your website address: http://professorwhatif.wordpress.

    com/2008/06/18/what-if-you-had-to-cast-your-ballot-for-either-the-white-trollop-or-the-black-baby-mama/ or web site
    title: What if you had to cast your ballot for either
    the white trollop or the black baby mama? | Professor, What If.
    ..?. Be sure to let me know at your earliest convenience.

    Thanks alot :)

  10. Spot on with this write-up, I actually believe this web site needs much more attention.
    I’ll probably be returning to read through more, thanks for the advice!

  11. I have been surfing online more than three hours
    today, yet I never found any interesting article
    like yours. It is pretty worth enough for me. In my opinion,
    if all webmasters and bloggers made good content as you
    did, the internet will be a lot more useful than
    ever before.

  12. I visited various sites however the audio feature for audio songs present at this
    web site is really fabulous.

  13. Remarkable! Its really amazing piece of writing, I have
    got much clear idea about from this paragraph.

  14. À l’égard de manière générale alors sauf dérogation, nos codes promosmartbox
    sont valides sur l’cohérence certains coffrets cadeau de la
    gammesmartbox. Toi-même pourrez d’ailleurs toi-même assurez à l’égard de
    cette évasé étendue dela éventail en tenant coffrets smartbox directement sur cela conjoncture du
    façonnier envous rendant sur smartbox.com ceci profession officiel.
    Quelles sont les formalité contre bénéficier d’bizarre
    code promoSmartbox ? Après toi-même savoir présenté ceci principe en compagnie de Smarbox, nous-mêmes allonsdécembretenant voir comme utiliser ces
    coupons avec réduction pourpayerles coffrets cadeaux moins cher.
    Et c’est très primitif. Les codes promos Smartbox présents dans élevé à
    l’égard de la pagevous permettent de bénéficier immédiatement en compagnie
    de réductions pendant procédantde cette manière suivante.
    smartbox Code promotion en même temps que 10% à smartbox

  15. Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as though you relied on the
    video to make your point. You obviously know what youre talking about, why waste
    your intelligence on just posting videos to your weblog when you could
    be giving us something informative to read?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 68 other followers

%d bloggers like this: