(Cross posted at In Media Res)

With Eclipse due to premiere in theatres this evening, this past week has been brimming with Twilight -related events. Last week, for example, a so-called “tent-city” brimmed with fans camping out in anticipation for the Friday night Los Angeles early-release premiere. Then, on Saturday evening, the night of the lunar eclipse, Summit Entertainment hosted “Twilight Night” events around the country that included celebrity appearances, live music, and back to back screening of the first two film adaptations.

A review of San Diego’s “Twilight Night” for Blast by Conception Allen reports such events reveal Twilight “fanaticism” continues to “cause hysterics.” Describing fans’ “ardent screams” and noting those turned away once the venue had reached capacity “threw tantrums,” the piece represents fans as temperamental toddlers.

Such a tone is typical in mainstream depictions of Twilighters that rather uniformly depict fans as childish and/or hyperfeminine. Words such as hysteria, fever, obsession, and mania are often deployed – words that the recent text Bitten by Twilight: Youth Culture, Media, and the Vampire Franchise aptly describe as “Victorian era gendered words.” This rendering of the fandom in terms that simultaneously infantilize and feminize it reflects the historical repudiation of females and femininity generally and the derision targeted at female fandoms more specifically.

Scholars such as Angela McRobbie and Milly Williamson document this enduring contempt for female fans, examining how cultural studies has tended to position male fans as resisting or subverting mainstream culture while female fans are either not considered at all or framed as dupes, uber-consumers, or, most often, as silly girls. This framing is particularly apparent with regards to the Twilight fandom, with fans depicted as crazy, frenzied hordes that shriek and gasp over “anything possessing a penis.”

This gendered backlash dismisses the productive and engaged nature of Twilight fandom, allowing for widespread ridicule that is not only about not liking Twilight but also participates in the historical tendency to mock that which females enjoy (such as romance novels, soap operas, teen idols, etc).

There are, however, exceptions. For example, the Vampire-Con Film Festival (which took place June 24 through June 26 in Los Angeles) distanced itself from the Twilight phenomenon via its promotional clip. Featuring an Edward-looking vampire enjoying the viewing pleasure of fellow cinema goers by “sparkling” in the theatre, this “All bite, No Sparkle” parody distances “real” vampire fans from Twilighters in a way that is humorous rather than derisive, clever rather than mocking. Similar to the “Vampires Protest Z Day” clip that promoted Vamp-Con 2009, this year’s video relies on parody rather than attacking the Twilight fandom directly or framing fans as “silly girls.” As such, the clip proves that differing fandoms can be critical of one another or disagree about what cultural products are deserving of fans without resorting to misogynistic laced disdain.

As argued by Melissa Click, the Twilight fandom “presents an opportunity to disrupt the persistent stereotypes about girls, the media they enjoy, and their cultural activities.” As she insists, cultural studies scholars must not “let the gendered mockery of Twilight fans continue unchallenged.” I agree entirely – Twilight may sparkle, but the critique of it need not bite…

4 thoughts on “What if Female Fans Matter? Taking a Bite of Out of Twilight Backlash

  1. “As argued by Melissa Click, the Twilight fandom “presents an opportunity to disrupt the persistent stereotypes about girls, the media they enjoy, and their cultural activities.””

    -Erm… does she know what the books are about? What is it that these fans find so attractive? It’s a story of a young woman who falls in love with an abusive guy, believes she cannot exist without some man in her life, sacrifices everything to be with a guy, gets married and starts immediately reproducing at 18, and marries off her daughter at the age of 6 to a former boyfriend.

    Which stereotypes exactly is that disrupting?

    This type of a deeply regressive female Bildungsroman that celebrates extremely patriarchal values has been enjoying a growing popularity in the US and in Western Europe in the past couple of decades. I wrote a book about this very same tendency in Spain, so I’m not surprised at the Twilight phenomenon. The tendencies underlying this development in the Bildungsroman genre should not be ignored. They should be feared by all who have any interest in women’s rights and gender equality.

  2. I think that using sexist words to describe the fans is a problem but I do think it is fair to deconstruct the current obsession with Twilight amongst women. What kind of woman is drawn into the Twilight world, and is she able to think critically about what is consuming are essential questions in my mind. I think that we cannot avoid examining gender in this case because it is women that are running the Twilight juggernaut.

  3. It would be interesting to do a content analysis of the words used to describe other “crazed fans” who camped out for movies. For example, what kind of words were used to describe those who camped out for Star Wars or Lord of the Rings? Compare that with those used to describe the Twilight campers.

    1. @Davo

      I think that people forget that star trek fans are looked at with disdain. People laugh at their devotion so the series and it is extremely popular.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s